How Google AI Overviews Affect Website Traffic (and What to Do About It)
AI Overviews answer many questions on the results page, so some sites get fewer clicks even when rankings hold. Here's what the research shows, how to diagnose it, and what to do.
Table of contents
Short answer: Google AI Overviews answer many questions directly on the results page, so fewer people click through, especially on informational queries. Pew Research Center found people clicked a traditional result in 8% of visits when an AI summary appeared, versus 15% without one. That's why traffic can fall while rankings stay the same. To respond: diagnose which queries are affected, earn citations inside AI Overviews, shift effort toward decision-stage and local queries, build brand demand, and convert more of the traffic you keep.
This guide covers the research, how to diagnose the impact on your site, and nine practical responses. For help, see our AI search optimization service.
What does the research show?
Pew Research Center (2025). Analysing real browsing data from 900 US adults in March 2025:
- Users clicked a traditional search result in 8% of visits when an AI summary appeared, compared with 15% when it didn't.
- Links inside the AI summary were clicked in only about 1% of visits.
- Users were more likely to end their browsing session after seeing an AI summary (26% vs 16%).
Seer Interactive (September 2025 update). Analysing more than 3,000 informational queries across 42 organisations:
- Organic CTR fell about 61% (from 1.76% to 0.61%) on queries with AI Overviews.
- Paid CTR on those queries fell about 68%.
- Even queries without AI Overviews saw organic CTR decline year over year.
- Brands cited in AI Overviews earned about 35% more organic clicks and 91% more paid clicks than those not cited (Seer notes this is correlation, not proven causation).
Scale matters too: Alphabet reported that AI Overviews had more than 2 billion monthly users by mid-2025.
Which queries are most affected?
| Query type | Example | Typical impact |
|---|---|---|
| Simple facts and definitions | "what is a roth ira" | High: answer fits in the overview |
| Basic how-to | "how to reset a router" | High |
| Complex research | "best crm for 50-person agency" | Medium: people still click to compare |
| Local intent | "dentist near me" | Lower: map pack and profiles dominate |
| Transactional | "buy running shoes size 10" | Lower |
| Brand / navigational | "[brand] login" | Low |
How to diagnose the impact on your site
- Search Console Performance report: compare the last three months with the same period last year. Look for queries where impressions held or rose but clicks and CTR fell. That pattern points to SERP features (often AI Overviews) rather than ranking losses.
- Group queries by intent: informational, commercial, local, brand. See where the losses concentrate.
- Check the Generative AI performance report in Search Console to see which pages appear in AI Overviews and AI Mode, by query, country and device.
- Spot-check key queries manually to see whether AI Overviews appear and whether you're cited.
- Look at conversions, not just sessions. Many sites find informational traffic fell but leads didn't fall as much, because the lost visits were low-intent.
9 ways to respond
1. Earn citations in AI Overviews
Being cited keeps you visible and, according to Seer's data, is associated with more clicks. Make each key page answer its question and likely sub-questions clearly, with unique information. See how to appear in Google AI Overviews.
2. Shift effort toward decision-stage queries
Comparisons, pricing, "best for", alternatives, local and service queries still drive clicks and convert better. Rebalance your content plan toward them.
3. Create non-commodity content
Google's guidance contrasts generic commodity content with unique, experienced, expert content. AI Overviews easily summarise commodity content; they send people to sources with original data, tools, detailed walkthroughs and real experience.
4. Build things people need to click for
Calculators, templates, comparison tools, configurators, booking flows, detailed case studies and downloadable resources can't be fully replaced by a summary.
5. Strengthen your brand
When AI answers mention brands, people search for them. Invest in brand-building channels (social video, PR, partnerships, email) so more people search for you directly. See is SEO dead because of AI?.
6. Diversify discovery
Spread visibility across channels that don't depend on one results page: AI assistants like ChatGPT and Perplexity, YouTube, social platforms, email newsletters and communities. See ChatGPT search vs Google.
7. Improve conversion of remaining traffic
Fewer but higher-intent visitors means each visit matters more. Improve calls to action, page speed, offers and forms.
8. Update your reporting
Report on impressions, AI citations, branded search growth and conversions, not just sessions. Explain to stakeholders that clicks per impression are falling across the industry.
9. Use the controls only deliberately
Search Console lets you exclude your site from Search generative AI features, and snippet controls can limit use. Excluding yourself removes your citation without restoring the clicks, so most businesses shouldn't.
A worked example
A home improvement blog sees organic sessions down 30% year over year while average position is stable. In Search Console, the biggest drops are on "how to" and "what is" queries; commercial pages ("cost of loft conversion in Leeds") are flat. The response:
- Rewrite the top 20 informational pages with original photos, cost data from real projects and clear answers to sub-questions, aiming for AI Overview citations.
- Build a cost calculator and a contractor checklist download.
- Expand commercial and local pages.
- Report leads and calculator use alongside sessions.
How to report this to leadership
Falling clicks with stable rankings can look like failure if it isn't explained. A simple framing:
- What changed: Google now answers many questions directly; industry research (Pew, Seer Interactive) shows fewer clicks when AI summaries appear.
- What it means for us: informational traffic is down X%; commercial and local traffic is stable or up; leads are [trend].
- What we're doing: earning citations in AI Overviews, shifting content toward decision-stage queries, building brand demand, improving conversion.
- How we'll measure: impressions and AI Overview visibility (Search Console's generative AI report), citations across assistants, organic and AI-referred leads.
Which pages to prioritise for recovery
| Page type | Action |
|---|---|
| High-impression informational pages losing clicks | Add unique data, examples and tools; aim for AI Overview citations |
| Commercial pages (pricing, comparisons, services) | Strengthen and expand; these still drive clicks |
| Local pages | Improve Business Profile and location content |
| Thin or overlapping informational posts | Merge into stronger guides |
| Pages already cited in AI Overviews | Keep updated; protect them |
Is all traffic loss bad?
Not necessarily. Some lost visits were people who only wanted a quick answer and would never have become customers. If leads and sales hold while sessions fall, your remaining visitors are likely more qualified. Focus reporting on outcomes, and watch whether brand searches and direct visits grow as AI answers mention you.
For the full picture of how AI search works and what to prioritise, read our complete guide to generative engine optimization (GEO).
The bottom line
AI Overviews are reducing clicks on many informational searches, and that trend isn't reversing. Diagnose which queries are affected, earn citations, focus on decision-stage and local content, create things worth clicking for, build brand demand and measure what matters.
Want to see how AI Overviews are affecting your traffic? Request a free growth audit. For the wider numbers, see our AI search statistics.
Frequently asked questions
Why is my website traffic dropping when rankings are the same?
Often because Google now shows AI Overviews or other features that answer the question on the results page. Fewer people click through, so impressions and rankings hold while clicks fall, especially on informational queries.
Do AI Overviews reduce clicks?
Research suggests they do on many queries. Pew Research Center found users clicked a traditional result 8% of the time when an AI summary appeared versus 15% without one. Seer Interactive found organic CTR down about 61% on informational queries with AI Overviews.
Can I stop my site from appearing in AI Overviews?
Search Console has a Search generative AI setting that lets you exclude your site, and snippet controls like nosnippet also limit use. But excluding yourself doesn't bring back clicks that AI Overviews absorb; it just removes your citation.
Which types of pages are most affected?
Informational pages that answer simple questions (definitions, quick facts, basic how-tos) tend to lose the most clicks. Commercial, local, transactional and brand queries are usually less affected.
Is being cited in AI Overviews worth it?
Seer Interactive's data suggests brands cited in AI Overviews earned more organic and paid clicks than those that weren't, though it couldn't prove causation. Being cited also builds visibility and trust.
Sources
Written by
SEO, AI search, paid media and social specialists
Articles from the MangoGrow editorial team are researched and written by our specialists in SEO, AI search, paid advertising, content, and social media, and reviewed before publishing.
More from MangoGrow